Where Do You Bury the Survivors?

  • Easy
  • Lateral thinking puzzles
  • Tests: Checking that the question is a question

The puzzle

An aircraft comes down exactly on the border between two countries. For a week the authorities on both sides argue about jurisdiction, treaty obligations and who should pay, and about where the survivors are to be buried.

Where should the survivors be buried?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Read the question once more and say out loud what the word "survivor" means.

Hint 2

The argument in the story is real enough. It is just about the wrong people.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Nowhere. Survivors are the ones who lived. You do not bury them.

How to get there

The question is built to occupy you with a genuinely hard problem - where a border runs, which country has jurisdiction over wreckage lying across it, what the treaties say - while the word that matters goes past unexamined. By the time you are weighing the merits of the two countries you have accepted that somebody is to be buried.

A survivor is, by definition, a person who did not die. There is nobody in the sentence to bury. The question is well formed, specific and polite, and it has no answer, because it presupposes something false - the same shape as "which prime number is even and greater than two".

This is worth more than a laugh, because real questions arrive in the same disguise. "Why is our retention dropping?" presupposes that it is dropping; "which of these two bugs caused the outage?" presupposes that one of them did. Answering either as asked produces a confident, well-researched answer to nothing.

The technique worth keeping

Before answering a question, check that it has an answer. Say its nouns out loud and ask whether each one describes anybody or anything at all - a false presupposition is invisible until you do.