The Coin in the Corked Bottle

  • Medium
  • Lateral thinking puzzles
  • Tests: Reading a constraint exactly as written

The puzzle

A coin lies at the bottom of an empty glass bottle. The neck is plugged with a cork pushed level with the top. The coin is narrower than the neck but far wider than any gap beside the cork.

Get the coin out. You may not break or cut the bottle, you may not remove the cork, and you may not damage the cork.

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

You are told the cork may not be removed. You are not told which way it may move.

Hint 2

Ask what the bottle actually has to keep where it is at the end.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Push the cork down the neck until it drops inside the bottle, then turn the bottle over and shake the coin out through the open neck.

How to get there

List the three constraints and test the move against each. The bottle must not be broken: pushing a cork inward breaks nothing. The cork must not be removed: pushed inward it is still inside the bottle, which is where it began, so it has not been removed from anything. The cork must not be damaged: a cork pressed down a neck it already fits comes through unmarked, whereas pulling one out with a screw does not.

Then check the geometry, because a solution that satisfies the rules and still leaves the coin inside is no solution. The coin is stated to be narrower than the neck, so once the neck is clear it will pass. The loose cork takes up room in the body of the bottle but cannot block the neck, and a bottle turned over and shaken will deliver the coin before it delivers a cork that has to turn end-on to fit.

The reason this feels like cheating is a misreading, not a loophole. "Do not remove the cork" gets heard as "the cork must stay in the neck", which is a stronger instruction than the one given. Once the stronger version is in your head the puzzle is genuinely impossible, which is why people stop looking - they are disproving a problem that was never set.

The technique worth keeping

Write each constraint down in the words you were given and test your move against those words, not against the stronger rule your mind supplied. Most "impossible" puzzles are impossible only under a restriction nobody imposed.