One Drank Fast, One Sipped

  • Medium
  • Lateral thinking puzzles
  • Tests: Finding the variable the story leaves open

The puzzle

Two men sit at the same bar and order the same iced drink, poured from the same bottle into identical glasses. One is thirsty and finishes his in about ten seconds, pays and leaves unharmed. The other sits talking and sips his for half an hour. He is dead before closing time.

Both glasses contained the poison, and it was meant for both men. How did the fast drinker survive?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

The two glasses held the same ingredients. Only one thing in a glass changes while it sits there.

Hint 2

It cannot have been in the bottle, or the barman would have been caught on the first glass he poured all evening.

Show the answer Hide the answer

The poison was frozen into the ice cubes. The fast drinker finished before the ice had melted enough to matter; the slow drinker sat for half an hour while his ice melted its full dose into the glass.

How to get there

Everything the story lets you vary is held equal: same bar, same bottle, same measure, same glass, both doses present. One variable is left open, and it is named twice - ten seconds against half an hour. So the cause has to be something whose effect depends on how long the glass sat, which rules out the liquid: a poison dissolved in the drink is swallowed whole by the fast drinker too.

Ice is the one ingredient that releases its contents gradually. Freeze the dose into the cubes and the amount actually in the drink is roughly the fraction of the ice that has melted. Half an hour is 1800 seconds, so the slow drinker gives his cubes 1800 / 10 = 180 times as long to melt as the fast one - the difference between most of the dose and almost none of it. That is ordinary pharmacology rather than a trick: a poison's effect follows the dose, and here the dose is a function of time.

The detail about the bottle is doing real work in the puzzle. It tells you the poison travelled with the glasses rather than with the drink, which is exactly what putting it in the ice achieves - and it is why the barman, who poured from that bottle all evening, is not the obvious suspect.

The technique worth keeping

When two cases differ in outcome, list everything the story holds equal and find what it leaves free. The free variable is the mechanism, and the right question becomes which ingredient could possibly depend on it.