Two Fathers and Two Sons
The puzzle
Two fathers and two sons go fishing. Each of them catches exactly one fish, and between them they catch three fish in total.
Nobody is lying and nobody threw a fish back. How?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
Four roles were mentioned. Were four people mentioned?
Hint 2
Can one person be a father and a son at the same time?
Show the answer Hide the answer
There are only three people: a grandfather, his son, and his son’s son. The middle man is both a father and a son.
How to get there
Count the roles: father, father, son, son. Count the people: the puzzle never says.
A grandfather, a father and a boy satisfy all four roles. The grandfather is a father; the middle man is a father and a son; the boy is a son.
Three people, one fish each, three fish. Nothing in the statement is stretched.
The technique worth keeping
Roles are not people. Whenever a puzzle counts descriptions rather than individuals, check whether one individual can satisfy several of them at once.