The Man in the Lift

  • Easy
  • Lateral thinking puzzles
  • Tests: Questioning an assumption the puzzle never stated

The puzzle

A man lives on the twentieth floor. Every morning he takes the lift all the way down. Every evening he takes it to the tenth floor and walks the rest.

Except when it is raining, or when somebody else is in the lift with him - then he rides all the way up. Why?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Nothing is wrong with the lift. The man is behaving perfectly rationally.

Hint 2

What do an umbrella and a fellow passenger have in common?

Show the answer Hide the answer

He is short. He can reach the button for the tenth floor but not the twentieth - unless he has an umbrella to poke it with, or somebody taller to press it for him.

How to get there

The two exceptions are the key, because a working explanation has to cover both. Rain and company are unrelated to lifts, so they must be related to each other through the man.

What rain gives him is an umbrella; what company gives him is another person’s arm. Both are ways of reaching higher than he can.

Going down needs only the ground-floor button, which is at the bottom of the panel - which is why the morning trip was never a problem.

The technique worth keeping

The puzzle never said how tall he is, and the solver supplies an average height without noticing. When a story seems to have no explanation, list what you assumed rather than what you were told.