In On Friday, Out On Friday
The puzzle
A cowboy rides into town on Friday. He stays three nights and rides out on Friday.
No clock or calendar has been tampered with, he did not cross a date line, and nothing in the story is false. How?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
Do the arithmetic. Friday plus three nights does not come back to Friday.
Hint 2
Only one of the two Fridays has to be a day of the week.
Show the answer Hide the answer
His horse is called Friday. He rode in on Friday, stayed three nights, and rode out on the same horse. Nothing in the story says which day of the week he arrived.
How to get there
First prove the obvious reading is impossible, so you know the puzzle is not simply asking you to count badly. Number the days with Monday as 1, which puts Friday at 5. Three nights later is day 5 + 3 = 8, and taking away a full week of 7 leaves day 1 - Monday. Weekdays repeat every seven days and three is not a multiple of seven, so if both Fridays were days of the week the story would be a flat contradiction.
That forces one of the two Fridays to be something else, and the sentence quietly allows it. "Rides into town on Friday" can mean on that day, or on that horse - English uses the same preposition for a date and for a mount. The first Friday is the horse; the second is a day of the week, or another ride on the same animal. Either way both statements are true at once.
The three nights are chosen with care. Seven nights would make the straight reading work and there would be no puzzle; three is small enough that a reader can count it on their fingers and feel the contradiction immediately, which is what pushes them to look for a second meaning rather than a calendar error.
The technique worth keeping
When a short statement is provably self-contradictory, the fault is usually a single word carrying two meanings rather than a mistake in the facts. Find the word that could mean something else and the contradiction dissolves.