Six Glasses, One Move

  • Easy
  • Lateral thinking puzzles
  • Tests: Separating the container from the contents

The puzzle

Six glasses stand in a row. The first three are full of water; the last three are empty. You want the row to alternate - full, empty, full, empty, full, empty - from left to right.

You are allowed to pick up exactly one glass. How do you do it?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Try it by moving glasses around and you will find one lift is never enough. So the lift is not what fixes the row.

Hint 2

A glass and the water in it are two different things.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Pick up the second glass, pour its water into the fifth, and put the empty glass back where it came from. The row now reads full, empty, full, empty, full, empty. Exactly one glass was lifted.

How to get there

Write the row as FFFEEE and the target as FEFEFE and compare them position by position. Positions 1, 3, 4 and 6 already agree. Only positions 2 and 5 are wrong, and they are wrong in opposite directions: 2 is full and should be empty, 5 is empty and should be full. Two errors, pointing opposite ways, is the signature of a single transfer.

That is what a pour is. Moving a glass to another place corrects at most the place it came from, so one lift cannot mend two positions - which is why the rearranging approach fails no matter how long you try it. Pouring mends both at once, because the water that leaves position 2 is the same water that arrives at position 5. One lift, two corrections.

Nothing is smuggled in. The row holds 6 / 2 = 3 full glasses and 3 empty ones before the pour and the same 3 and 3 after it, so no water is added or thrown away - and a solution that tipped water onto the floor would still leave position 5 empty and the row wrong. The puzzle reads as impossible only while "move a glass" is heard as "move a glass and everything in it".

The technique worth keeping

Count how many positions are wrong, and in which direction, before you start moving things. Two errors in opposite directions can usually be fixed by one transfer between them, which is a cheaper operation than one rearrangement.