The Second Hand Laps the Minute Hand

  • Medium
  • Clock and calendar puzzles
  • Tests: Counting laps rather than meetings

The puzzle

In one hour the second hand goes round sixty times and the minute hand once.

How many times does the second hand overtake the minute hand in that hour?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Sixty laps sounds like sixty overtakings. Count what the minute hand is doing meanwhile.

Hint 2

Only the RELATIVE motion produces an overtaking.

Show the answer Hide the answer

59.

How to get there

An overtaking happens once per lap of the second hand RELATIVE to the minute hand, not per lap of the dial. In an hour the second hand completes 60 laps and the minute hand 1, so the second hand gains 60 − 1 = 59 laps on it.

So there are 59 overtakings, spaced 60/59 minutes apart - every 61.0169 seconds, not every 60.

The same arithmetic explains why the hour and minute hands meet 11 times in 12 hours rather than 12: the minute hand completes 12 laps and the hour hand 1, so it gains 11. Any two hands overtake a number of times equal to the difference in their lap counts.

The technique worth keeping

Overtakings count relative laps, not absolute ones. Subtract the slower object's revolutions from the faster one's, and the difference is the answer - which is why the count is always one short of what the fast hand alone suggests.