Hands at a Right Angle

  • Medium
  • Clock and calendar puzzles
  • Tests: Counting in relative speed

The puzzle

An ordinary twelve-hour clock has an hour hand and a minute hand that move smoothly.

In twenty-four hours, how many times are the two hands exactly ninety degrees apart?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Work with the angle between the hands and how fast it changes, not with the time.

Hint 2

The minute hand gains on the hour hand at a steady rate - how many full laps does it gain in twelve hours?

Show the answer Hide the answer

Forty-four times - twenty-two in each twelve-hour period.

How to get there

The minute hand turns 360 degrees an hour, the hour hand 30, so the gap between them grows at 330 degrees an hour. In twelve hours it grows by 3960 degrees, which is eleven full laps.

In each lap of the gap there are exactly two moments at a right angle: once at 90 degrees and once at 270.

Eleven laps times two is 22 right angles in twelve hours, so 44 in a day. Not 48, which is what counting four per hour would wrongly give.

The technique worth keeping

Track the difference rather than the two positions. Relative speed turns every clock question - overlaps, straight lines, right angles - into counting laps of a single moving gap.