How Often the Hands Meet

  • Medium
  • Clock and calendar puzzles
  • Tests: Counting laps of the gap, not hours

The puzzle

The hour and minute hands of an ordinary twelve-hour clock move smoothly.

In a full day of twenty-four hours, how many times do they lie exactly on top of one another?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

The obvious answer is 24, once an hour. Check the hour between 11 and 1.

Hint 2

Count how many laps the minute hand gains on the hour hand in twelve hours.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Twenty-two - eleven in each twelve-hour period, not twelve.

How to get there

The minute hand turns 360 degrees an hour and the hour hand 30, so the minute hand gains 330 degrees an hour. In twelve hours it gains 3960 degrees, which is eleven complete laps.

Each lap gained is exactly one overlap, so there are eleven in twelve hours and twenty-two in a day.

The missing one is around 12 o’clock: the overlap near 11 and the one at 12 are the same event, which is why "once an hour" overcounts by one per half-day.

The technique worth keeping

Track the gap between the hands and count its laps. Every clock question - meeting, opposite, right angles - is the same single moving quantity measured against a different target angle.