When Do the Hands Meet After Four?

  • Medium
  • Clock and calendar puzzles
  • Tests: Catching one hand with another

The puzzle

At four o'clock the hour hand is ahead of the minute hand. At what exact time do they next point in the same direction?

4:20 is close, but at 4:20 the hour hand has moved on.

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

At 4:00 the hour hand leads by 120 degrees. The minute hand gains at 330 degrees an hour.

Hint 2

Work in minutes: the minute hand gains 5.5 degrees a minute.

Show the answer Hide the answer

4:21 and 9/11 minutes — about 4:21:49.

How to get there

At 4:00 the hour hand is at 120 degrees and the minute hand at 0, a gap of 120. The minute hand moves 6 degrees a minute and the hour hand 0.5, so the gap closes at 5.5 degrees a minute.

120/5.5 = 240/11 = 21.818 minutes. That is 21 minutes and 9/11 of a minute, which is 49.09 seconds.

At 4:20 the hour hand has reached 130 degrees while the minute hand is at 120 - still 10 degrees behind, which is why 4:20 is close but wrong. The hands meet eleven times in twelve hours, every 12/11 hours, and only the one at 12:00 falls on a whole minute.

The technique worth keeping

Treat it as a chase: find the starting gap and the rate at which it closes, then divide. The relative speed of the hands, 5.5 degrees a minute, answers every meeting, opposing and right-angle question on a clock face.