The Stopped Watch and the Slow One

  • Medium
  • Clock and calendar puzzles
  • Tests: Comparing a fixed error with a drifting one

The puzzle

One watch has stopped entirely. Another loses one minute every day but runs otherwise perfectly.

How often is each one exactly right? Which would you rather carry?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

The stopped watch shows one fixed time. How often does the real time match it?

Hint 2

The slow watch is right only when its error has grown to a whole number of dial revolutions.

Show the answer Hide the answer

The stopped watch is right twice a day. The slow one is right once every 720 days.

How to get there

The stopped watch reads some fixed time, say 7:10. On a twelve-hour dial the real time passes 7:10 twice in every 24 hours, so it is exactly right twice a day - 730 times a year.

The slow watch is right only when its accumulated error is a whole number of dial revolutions. One revolution is 12 hours = 720 minutes, and it loses 1 minute a day, so that takes 720 days - about once every two years.

So the broken watch is right far more often, which is the joke. It is also useless, and that is the real lesson: being exactly right occasionally is worth nothing against being nearly right always. The slow watch is never more than a few minutes out in its first year.

The technique worth keeping

Distinguish how OFTEN an instrument is exactly right from how FAR wrong it usually is. A drifting error returns to zero only after a whole period of the display, and frequency of exactness is a poor measure of accuracy.