Measuring a Building With a Barometer

  • Medium
  • Lateral thinking puzzles
  • Tests: Refusing to answer only the expected way

The puzzle

A physics examination asks: "Show how it is possible to determine the height of a tall building with the aid of a barometer."

The expected answer uses the difference in air pressure between the ground and the roof. Give as many other correct methods as you can.

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

The question says "with the aid of" a barometer. It does not say you must measure pressure.

Hint 2

A barometer is also an object with a known length, a known mass, and a resale value.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Drop it from the roof and time the fall; lower it on a string and measure the string; use it as a ruler against the wall; compare its shadow with the building's; swing it as a pendulum at top and bottom; or offer it to the caretaker in exchange for the answer.

How to get there

Timing a fall: drop the barometer from the roof and measure the time t. The height is about 4.9 * t^2 metres. A 3-second fall means roughly 44 m.

Using it as a length: lower it on a string until it touches the ground, then measure the string. Or lay it end over end up the stairwell and count. Or measure the barometer and its shadow, measure the building's shadow, and scale by similar triangles - the same method that gives the lamppost puzzle's answer.

Using it as a pendulum: a pendulum's period depends on gravity, which is very slightly weaker at the top of the building, so comparing the period at both ends gives the height - impractically small, but correct. And the method the story is really about: give the barometer to the building's caretaker in exchange for being told the height. The question asked for a method, not for the method the examiner had in mind.

The technique worth keeping

Read what a question actually permits rather than what it seems to want. Listing the properties of the objects you are given - length, mass, value, the shadow it casts - generates alternatives that the intended answer hides.