The Job Handed Over

  • Medium
  • Work, speed and rate puzzles
  • Tests: Converting work remaining into a rate

The puzzle

Ana can paint a house alone in 10 days. She works for 4 days and then leaves. Ben takes over and finishes the remaining work in 9 days.

How long would Ben have taken to paint the whole house by himself?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

How much of the house did Ana paint in her 4 days?

Hint 2

Ben's 9 days covered whatever was left. Scale that up to the whole job.

Show the answer Hide the answer

15 days.

How to get there

Ana paints 1/10 of the house per day, so in 4 days she does 4/10 = 2/5 of it. That leaves 3/5 for Ben.

Ben did 3/5 of the house in 9 days, so his rate is (3/5)/9 = 1/15 of the house per day. The whole job alone would take him 15 days.

Checking the other way round: in 9 days at 1/15 per day Ben does 9/15 = 3/5. Together with Ana's 2/5 that is the whole house. Note Ben is slower than Ana - 15 days against 10 - which the 9 days he spent on the larger share already suggested.

The technique worth keeping

Turn elapsed work into a fraction of the job, then divide by the time taken to get a rate. "Work done = rate x time" rearranges three ways, and the fraction remaining is always 1 minus what is finished.