The Coin Dated 544 BC
The puzzle
A dealer offers you an ancient bronze coin, clearly struck and clearly old, stamped with the date 544 BC.
Without examining the metal, how do you know it is not genuine?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
What does BC stand for, and when did people start using it?
Hint 2
A coin maker in 544 BC had no way of knowing what they were counting down to.
Show the answer Hide the answer
BC means "before Christ", a system invented centuries after the event it counts from. Nobody in 544 BC could have known they were in 544 BC.
How to get there
The BC/AD scheme was devised by Dionysius Exiguus in the sixth century AD and only came into common use centuries later still. Dating backwards from the birth of Christ requires knowing when that was - and that it was going to matter.
A mint in 544 BC would have dated its coins by whatever local system it used: a ruler's regnal year, an Olympiad, the founding of a city. Greek and Roman coins carry exactly those markings, not countdowns.
So the stamp gives it away without any metallurgy at all. The same reasoning catches other anachronisms: a film prop labelled "Ancient Rome, 50 BC", or a document dated with a year its writer could not have used.
The technique worth keeping
Test a claim against the conventions that would have had to exist for it to be true. An anachronism is a logical impossibility, not merely an improbability, and it needs no physical evidence to detect.