The Race the Slower Horse Wins

  • Medium
  • Lateral thinking puzzles
  • Tests: Changing what you control rather than what you do

The puzzle

A rich man tells his two sons to race their horses to a distant town. The son whose horse arrives last will inherit the fortune.

The sons set off, and within an hour both have stopped, each refusing to move ahead of the other. They sit there for two days. A passing stranger offers one word of advice, and they immediately gallop off at full speed. What was the word?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

The condition is about the horses, not the riders.

Hint 2

Each son wants his own horse to be last. What if he were not riding it?

Show the answer Hide the answer

"Swap." Each son rides the other's horse - and now wants to come first, because arriving first means his own horse came last.

How to get there

The will says the son whose horse comes last inherits. Riding his own horse, each son wants to be last, so both dawdle and neither can afford to move - a perfect deadlock.

Swap the horses. Now each son is riding his brother's horse, and getting his own horse to finish last means getting the horse he is riding to finish first. Both race flat out, and the result is a genuine test of the horses.

The condition was never changed - the slower horse still wins the fortune - but the incentive was reversed. The deadlock came from asking two people to compete at losing, which is a race with no finishing line.

The technique worth keeping

When everyone's incentives point the wrong way, look for a swap that realigns them instead of a rule that forbids the behaviour. Changing who holds what often fixes what changing the rules cannot.