Weighing an Elephant

  • Easy
  • Lateral thinking puzzles
  • Tests: Measuring by substitution

The puzzle

A village owns an elephant and no scales big enough to put it on. What the village does have is a river, a flat-bottomed boat large enough to carry the animal, a heap of stones and an ordinary balance that can weigh anything one person can lift.

Find the weight of the elephant to within a few kilograms. You may not harm the elephant and you may not build anything.

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

You are not required to weigh the elephant. You are required to produce its weight - which you can do by weighing anything you can prove weighs the same.

Hint 2

Walk the elephant onto the boat and watch the waterline.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Lead the elephant onto the boat and scratch a mark on the hull at the waterline. Lead it off again, then load stones until the boat settles to exactly that mark. Weigh the stones one at a time and add them up: the total is the weight of the elephant.

How to get there

A floating boat sinks until the water it pushes aside weighs exactly what the boat and its load weigh together - that is Archimedes. So the waterline is not a measure of bulk or of how the load is arranged; it is a reading of total weight. Two loads that sink the same boat to the same mark weigh the same, whatever they are made of.

Put numbers on it. An elephant of 4200 kg pushes aside 4200 kg of fresh water, which at 1000 kg per cubic metre is 4200 / 1000 = 4.2 cubic metres. Replace the elephant with stones and the boat returns to the same mark only when the stones also displace 4.2 cubic metres - that is, only when they also weigh 4200 kg. The balance can then do the work in pieces: at 30 kg a stone, 4200 / 30 = 140 weighings, each one well within what it can handle.

The accuracy is limited by how finely you can read the waterline, not by the balance. A mark you can judge to a millimetre on a boat with four square metres of waterplane is four litres of water, which is four kilograms - about a tenth of one per cent of the answer. This is the story told of Cao Chong in third-century China, and it is still how a ship's cargo is weighed today: a draught survey reads the marks on the hull and converts them to tonnes.

The technique worth keeping

When the thing in front of you cannot be measured directly, do not look for a bigger instrument. Look for something you can prove is equal to it and measure that instead, in as many small pieces as your instrument needs.