One More Cow on the Common

  • Medium
  • Game strategy puzzles
  • Tests: Comparing private gain with shared cost

The puzzle

Ten herders share a common pasture. Each extra cow one of them adds earns that herder the full value of the cow, but the extra grazing damages the pasture for all ten.

What does each herder do, and what happens to the pasture?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Work out what share of the damage the herder who adds the cow actually bears.

Hint 2

If the benefit is all yours and the cost is one tenth yours, when do you stop?

Show the answer Hide the answer

Each adds cows until the pasture is ruined. The herder takes 100% of the gain and bears only 1/10 of the cost — so adding is profitable long past the point where it is collectively sensible.

How to get there

Adding a cow gives the owner its whole value. The damage is shared among ten, so the owner bears a tenth of it - and pays 0.9 of the cost to somebody else.

So a cow is worth adding to its owner whenever its value exceeds a tenth of the damage it causes, while it is worth adding collectively only when it exceeds the whole damage. Every cow in between is individually rational and collectively destructive, and each herder reasons the same way.

The pasture is grazed to ruin and everybody ends up worse off. It is the prisoner's dilemma with ten players and a continuous choice. The known remedies are all structural - divide the common into private plots, set and police a quota, or tax the grazing so the owner bears the full cost - because exhortation does not change the arithmetic.

The technique worth keeping

Compare the private share of the benefit with the private share of the cost. Whenever an actor captures all of one and a fraction of the other, over-use follows from rational behaviour, and only changing who bears the cost will stop it.