A Spoonful Each Way

  • Hard
  • Logical puzzles
  • Tests: Conserving volume instead of tracking molecules

The puzzle

Two glasses hold equal amounts, one of wine and one of water. A spoonful of wine is stirred into the water. Then a spoonful of that mixture is stirred back into the wine.

Is there now more wine in the water glass, or more water in the wine glass?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Do not try to track how much wine came back. Track the volumes.

Hint 2

Both glasses end with exactly as much liquid as they started with.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Exactly the same amount of each - however carelessly the stirring was done.

How to get there

Both glasses end at their original volume, because each gave away one spoonful and received one.

So whatever water is now missing from the water glass has been replaced by exactly that volume of wine - there is nothing else it could be replaced by.

The wine now in the water glass equals the water now in the wine glass. The argument never mentions how well the mixture was stirred, which is why it holds even if it was not stirred at all.

The technique worth keeping

Find the quantity that is conserved and reason about it instead of the process. A volume argument settles in one line what tracking concentrations would take a page to get wrong.