Three Mislabelled Boxes
The puzzle
Three boxes hold apples, oranges, and a mixture. Each is labelled, and you are told that every single label is wrong.
You may draw one fruit, without looking inside, from one box of your choosing. Relabel all three correctly.
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
Which box tells you most? Not the ones labelled with a single fruit.
Hint 2
The box labelled "mixture" cannot be the mixture.
Show the answer Hide the answer
Draw from the box labelled MIXTURE. Whatever you get is that box’s only fruit, and the other two follow by elimination.
How to get there
Every label is wrong, so the box marked MIXTURE is not mixed - it is pure apples or pure oranges. One fruit therefore identifies it completely.
Say you draw an apple. That box is the apples, and the two remaining contents are oranges and the mixture. Take the box marked ORANGES: its label is wrong, so it is not the oranges, which leaves only the mixture.
The last box, marked APPLES, takes what is left: the oranges. One draw fixes all three, because the "every label is wrong" guarantee rules out one option in each box, and two eliminations are enough to finish a three-way choice.
The technique worth keeping
A constraint that applies to every case is worth more than one that applies to one. "All labels are wrong" turns one observation into three deductions, which no single draw could manage on its own.