One Question to the Islander

  • Hard
  • Logical puzzles
  • Tests: Building a question whose answer is the same from either

The puzzle

You reach a fork. One road leads to the city, one to the swamp. A single islander stands there; islanders either always tell the truth or always lie, and you cannot tell which this one is.

You may ask one yes-or-no question. What do you ask?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

A question about the world gets opposite answers from the two kinds. You need one that does not.

Hint 2

Make the question refer to what the OTHER kind would say.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Ask: "If I asked you whether the left road leads to the city, would you say yes?" Then take the left road if the answer is yes.

How to get there

A truth-teller reports honestly what they would say, so their answer matches reality.

A liar must lie about what they would say - and what they would say is already a lie. Two lies cancel, so their answer also matches reality.

So both kinds give the same answer, and that answer is the truth. The nesting is what makes the speaker’s nature irrelevant.

The technique worth keeping

When an unknown flips your information, apply it twice. A question embedded in itself forces the liar to negate a negation, and the same trick answers every "two guards, one question" variant.