The Monk on the Mountain

  • Medium
  • Logical puzzles
  • Tests: Superimposing two journeys into one

The puzzle

A monk climbs a mountain path starting at dawn and reaching the top by dusk, resting and varying his pace as he likes. The next day he descends the same path, again from dawn to dusk.

Must there be a point on the path he passes at exactly the same time of day on both journeys?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Do not think about one monk on two days. Think about two monks on one day.

Hint 2

Two people walking towards each other along the same path must meet.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Yes, always - and the proof does not require knowing anything about his pace.

How to get there

Imagine both journeys happening on the same day: one monk starting at the bottom at dawn, another starting at the top at dawn, each following the day’s schedule.

They are on the same path, moving in opposite directions, both travelling from dawn to dusk. They must pass each other at some moment.

The place and time where they pass is the point the single monk occupied at the same time of day on both journeys. No calculation is needed and none would help, because the paces are unknown.

The technique worth keeping

Overlay the two scenarios and look for a crossing. It is the intermediate value theorem in disguise: a continuous difference that starts positive and ends negative must be zero somewhere.