Walking Up the Escalator

  • Hard
  • Work, speed and rate puzzles
  • Tests: Adding your rate to the machine’s

The puzzle

An escalator is moving upwards at a steady rate. Walking up it at your normal pace you reach the top having taken 20 steps of your own. Strolling at half that pace - so each step takes twice as long - you reach the top having taken only 15.

How many steps does the escalator have when it is standing still?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

The escalator contributes steps while you walk, and contributes more when you take longer.

Hint 2

Write the total as your steps plus the escalator’s steps during your trip.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Thirty steps.

How to get there

Say the escalator adds e steps per one of your steps. Walking: 20 + 20e = N. Strolling at half the pace takes twice as long per step, so the escalator adds 2e per step: 15 + 30e = N.

Setting them equal: 20 + 20e = 15 + 30e, so 5 = 10e and e = 0.5.

Then N = 20 + 20(0.5) = 30 steps. Checking the second: 15 + 30(0.5) = 30 too.

The technique worth keeping

Count the total in a unit both parties contribute to - here steps of staircase - and write one equation per scenario. Two scenarios give two equations, which is exactly enough for two unknowns.