Beating Him by Twenty Metres

  • Medium
  • Work, speed and rate puzzles
  • Tests: Converting a lead in distance into a ratio

The puzzle

In a 100 metre race, A beats B by 20 metres - when A finishes, B has run 80.

If A now gives B a 20 metre head start over the same 100 metres, who wins?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Turn the first race into a ratio of speeds rather than a gap.

Hint 2

In the second race, how far does each of them have to run?

Show the answer Hide the answer

They dead-heat. Both reach the line at the same instant.

How to get there

In the first race A runs 100 while B runs 80, so A’s speed is to B’s as 100 is to 80, which is 5 to 4.

In the second race A runs 100 and B runs only 80, because of the head start.

The distances are in the same 5 : 4 ratio as the speeds, so the times are equal. A dead heat - not the win that "giving away his advantage" suggests.

The technique worth keeping

Convert a margin into a ratio before changing the conditions. A lead measured in metres is not portable between races; a ratio of speeds is.