Down the Up Escalator

  • Hard
  • Work, speed and rate puzzles
  • Tests: Subtracting the machine from the walker

The puzzle

An escalator has 60 visible steps and moves upwards at 1 step per second. You walk DOWN it at 3 steps per second.

How long does it take to reach the bottom, and how many steps do you actually tread on?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Your speed relative to the ground is your walking speed minus the escalator's.

Hint 2

But the number of steps you tread on is counted at your walking rate, not your ground rate.

Show the answer Hide the answer

30 seconds, and you tread on 90 steps — half as long again as the escalator has.

How to get there

Relative to the ground you descend at 3 − 1 = 2 steps per second. The 60 steps therefore take 60/2 = 30 seconds.

In those 30 seconds you take 3 steps a second, so you tread on 90 steps - more than the escalator contains, because the escalator kept bringing steps back up under your feet.

Going the other way, walking UP at 3 while it rises at 1, you would reach the top in 60/4 = 15 seconds having trodden on only 45 steps. The number of visible steps is the same; what changes is how many pass beneath you.

The technique worth keeping

Separate two rates that look like one: progress over the ground uses the relative speed, while effort expended uses your own. Confusing them is why escalator questions have two different-looking answers.