There and Back Against the Wind

  • Medium
  • Work, speed and rate puzzles
  • Tests: Showing that a symmetric help and hindrance do not cancel

The puzzle

A cyclist rides 15 km/h in still air. Today there is a 5 km/h wind: the outward leg is at 20 km/h and the return at 10.

The wind helps as much as it hinders. Is the round trip faster, slower or the same as on a calm day?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

The average speed over equal distances is the harmonic mean, not the arithmetic one.

Hint 2

More TIME is spent on the slow leg than on the fast one.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Slower — 13.33 km/h against 15. The wind always costs, whichever direction it blows.

How to get there

Equal distances at 20 and 10 give an average of 2 × 20 × 10/(20 + 10) = 400/30 = 13.33 km/h, below the calm-day 15.

The reason is time, not distance. Over 20 km each way, the fast leg takes 1 hour and the slow leg 2 - so two thirds of the ride is spent at the slower speed, and the average is dragged towards it.

It is true for any wind speed: the harmonic mean of v+w and v−w is (v² − w²)/v, which is always less than v for any non-zero w. A stronger wind costs more, and a wind as strong as the cyclist makes the return leg impossible.

The technique worth keeping

For equal distances, use the harmonic mean. A symmetric gain and loss in SPEED is never symmetric in TIME, because the slow leg lasts longer - which is why any round-trip disturbance costs you.