Guess Two Thirds of the Average
The puzzle
Everybody in a large group secretly picks a number from 0 to 100. The winner is whoever is closest to two thirds of the average of all the numbers chosen.
What should you pick? And what actually wins when real people play?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
If everybody picked 100, two thirds of the average would be 66.7 - so no answer above that can ever win.
Hint 2
Now repeat that argument with 66.7 as the new ceiling, and again.
Show the answer Hide the answer
The only equilibrium is 0, but in practice the winning number is usually between 20 and 35 — because real players stop reasoning after a step or two.
How to get there
The highest possible average is 100, so the target can never exceed 66.7. Nobody should pick above that. But if everybody knows that, the average cannot exceed 66.7 and the target cannot exceed 44.4. Repeating drives the ceiling down to 0.
So 0 is the unique Nash equilibrium: if everybody picks 0, nobody can do better by changing. Picking 0 is right only if everybody else reasons all the way down too.
They do not. In large public runs of this game the winning answer is typically 20 to 35. Most people do one or two rounds of the reasoning - 66.7, then 44 - and stop. Picking 0 against such a crowd loses badly. The right play is not the equilibrium but an estimate of how many steps your opponents will take, which is why Keynes compared it to picking the face a newspaper competition will judge prettiest.
The technique worth keeping
Separate "what is the equilibrium" from "what will these opponents do". Iterated elimination finds the equilibrium; winning requires modelling how many rounds of that elimination the other players will actually perform.