Both Better Off, Both Confess

  • Medium
  • Game strategy puzzles
  • Tests: Seeing that individual logic can beat collective sense

The puzzle

Two suspects are questioned separately. If both stay silent they get 1 year each. If both confess, 2 years each. If one confesses and the other stays silent, the confessor walks free and the silent one gets 3 years.

What should each do? And what will they do?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Work out the best reply for one prisoner in each of the two cases the other could choose.

Hint 2

If confessing is better whatever the other does, the reasoning never depends on trust.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Each should confess — confessing beats silence whatever the other does — and so both get 2 years, when staying silent would have given them 1 each.

How to get there

Suppose the other stays silent. Confessing gives you 0 years and silence gives 1, so confess. Suppose the other confesses. Confessing gives 2 and silence gives 3, so confess again.

Confessing is better in both cases - it is a dominant strategy - so a prisoner reasoning only about their own sentence confesses without needing to guess what the other will do. Both confess and both serve 2 years, which is the worse of the two symmetric outcomes.

Nothing here is irrational. Each prisoner has done exactly what is best for themselves, and the result is worse for both than the outcome they could have had. That gap between individual and collective interest is the point, and it is why real versions - arms races, overfishing, price wars - need enforceable agreements rather than good intentions. Repeat the game indefinitely and cooperation becomes rational again, because defecting now costs you later.

The technique worth keeping

Check for a dominant strategy first: compute your best reply to each of the opponent's options, and if one choice wins every time, the game is settled without any reasoning about the opponent at all.