One of Them Cannot Row
The puzzle
Four people must cross a river in a canoe that seats two. One of them has an injured arm and cannot paddle at all, so he may only travel as a passenger.
Can they all get across, and does the injury cost them any extra crossings?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
A canoe returning must have a paddler in it, so the injured man can never make a return trip.
Hint 2
Send him across once, early, with somebody who can bring the canoe back.
Show the answer Hide the answer
Yes, in five crossings — the same as if everybody could paddle. The injury costs nothing.
How to get there
Call the paddlers A, B, C and the injured man D. A takes D across; A paddles back alone; B and C cross together; B paddles back; A and B cross. Five crossings, and D travelled exactly once.
Five is also the minimum for four people in a two-seat boat with no constraint at all: two round trips move two people across, and the final crossing moves the last two.
So the injury changes which plans work but not how many crossings are needed. It would matter if TWO people could not paddle, because then a pair of non-paddlers would have to cross together and there would be nobody to bring the canoe back.
The technique worth keeping
Before assuming a constraint costs something, find the unconstrained minimum and try to achieve it anyway. Many restrictions only remove some of the optimal plans and leave at least one standing.