Bidding for a Pound
The puzzle
A £1 coin is auctioned with one unusual rule: the highest bidder wins the coin, but the SECOND highest bidder must also pay their bid and gets nothing.
Bidding starts at 1p. Where does it end, and what should you do?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
Once you are the second-highest bidder, what does raising your bid by a penny cost you compared with stopping?
Hint 2
Work out the comparison when the bids are 99p and £1.
Show the answer Hide the answer
Do not bid at all. Once two people are in, each has a reason to bid again at every point, and the coin routinely sells for several times its value.
How to get there
Suppose the bids are 99p and £1. The 99p bidder faces a choice: stop and lose 99p, or bid £1.01 and - if that wins - pay £1.01 for a coin worth £1, losing only 1p. Losing a penny beats losing 99, so they raise.
That comparison never goes away. At every point the trailing bidder is choosing between a certain loss of their whole bid and a smaller loss from winning, so there is always a reason to bid once more. Bids of £3 and £4 for a £1 coin are routinely recorded when this is run in classrooms.
The error is treating money already bid as part of the decision. It is spent either way - a sunk cost - and the only sound question is whether the NEXT penny is worth it, which, taken on its own, it never is. The one winning move is not to enter, which is also the lesson for price wars and for projects that are "too far along to stop".
The technique worth keeping
When each successive step looks individually rational and the sequence is ruinous, look for a sunk cost in the comparison. Decide by the value of the next move alone, and check at the outset whether any entry point is safe.