Two Coins, Thirty Cents
The puzzle
You have two coins totalling thirty cents. One of them is not a nickel.
What are the two coins?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
The sentence says one of them is not a nickel. It says nothing about the other.
Hint 2
Which pair of American coins adds to thirty?
Show the answer Hide the answer
A quarter and a nickel. The quarter is the one that is not a nickel.
How to get there
Twenty-five and five are the only two coins that add to thirty, so the pair is forced before the clue is even used.
"One of them is not a nickel" is true of that pair: the quarter is not a nickel.
The trap is hearing it as "neither of them is a nickel", which is a much stronger statement and is not what was said.
The technique worth keeping
Read quantifiers exactly. "One is not" and "neither is" differ by everything, and the same slip turns up wherever a specification is read as stronger than it was written.