Two Ferries, Two Meetings

  • Hard
  • River crossing puzzles
  • Tests: Counting total distance instead of speeds

The puzzle

Two ferries leave opposite banks of a river at the same moment, each at its own constant speed. They pass each other 720 m from the near bank. Each continues, turns round at the far bank without pausing, and they pass again 400 m from the other bank.

How wide is the river? You are not told either speed.

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

At the first meeting the two ferries have together covered one river width.

Hint 2

By the second meeting, how many widths have they covered between them?

Show the answer Hide the answer

1760 m.

How to get there

At the first meeting the ferries between them have covered exactly one width, W. The ferry from the near bank has done 720 of it.

By the second meeting each has crossed and come partway back, so between them they have covered 3W. Speeds are constant and both ferries travelled for the same time, so each ferry has covered three times what it had at the first meeting: the near-bank ferry has gone 3 x 720 = 2160 m.

That ferry reached the far bank, a distance W, and then came back 400 m, so its total is W + 400. Therefore W + 400 = 2160 and W = 1760 m. Neither speed was needed - only the fact that both ferries are always three times as far along as they were at the first meeting.

The technique worth keeping

For objects moving at constant speed over the same interval, distances scale together. Count the combined distance at each event - one width, then three - and the ratio does the work that solving for speeds would have done.