Straight Across a Current
The puzzle
A river 100 m wide flows at 3 km/h. A boat rows at 5 km/h through the water. The rower wants to land at the point directly opposite the start, not downstream of it.
How long does the crossing take?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
To land directly opposite, the boat must point upstream so that the current exactly cancels the upstream part of its motion.
Hint 2
The 5 km/h splits into an upstream component of 3 and a cross-river component - use Pythagoras.
Show the answer Hide the answer
90 seconds. The useful cross-river speed is 4 km/h, not 5.
How to get there
Aim upstream at the angle where the boat's upstream component is exactly 3 km/h, cancelling the current. The remaining component points straight across, and since the total speed through the water is 5, that component is sqrt(5^2 - 3^2) = sqrt(16) = 4 km/h.
The crossing is 100 m = 0.1 km at 4 km/h, which takes 0.025 h = 90 seconds.
Had the rower simply pointed straight across, the full 5 km/h would have gone into crossing and the trip would have taken 0.1/5 h = 72 seconds - but the boat would have landed 60 m downstream. Insisting on the landing point costs 18 seconds, which is the price of the 3 km/h spent fighting the current.
The technique worth keeping
Resolve a velocity into the direction you care about and the direction you must cancel. The constraint fixes one component, Pythagoras gives the other, and the time follows from the useful component alone.