The Hat and the Bridge
The puzzle
A man rowing upstream passes under a bridge, and his hat falls into the water there. He rows on for five minutes before noticing, then turns and rows back downstream at the same effort.
How long after turning does he reach his hat? You are not told the speed of the current, and you do not need it.
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
The hat is not swimming anywhere. It is simply drifting with the water.
Hint 2
Imagine the whole river is a moving walkway, and describe the man's motion relative to the water rather than to the bank.
Show the answer Hide the answer
Five minutes - the same time he spent rowing away from it.
How to get there
Measure everything relative to the water. The hat floats with the current, so in the water's frame it does not move at all. The man rows at the same speed relative to the water in both directions.
So in that frame he moves away from a stationary hat for five minutes, then turns and moves back towards it at the same speed. He takes five minutes to return.
The current is irrelevant because it carries the man and the hat equally - it shifts the whole scene downstream without changing their separation. In the bank's frame the sums are messy and the current appears in several places; in the water's frame it appears nowhere, and the answer is immediate.
The technique worth keeping
Choose the reference frame in which the troublesome motion disappears. When something drifts passively with a medium, work relative to that medium - the drift stops being part of the problem.