The Warden's Answer

  • Medium
  • Probability puzzles
  • Tests: Asking whether an answer could have gone another way

The puzzle

Three prisoners, A, B and C, are told one will be pardoned at random and the other two hanged. A asks the warden to name one of B or C who will hang. The warden, who knows the outcome and will never name A, says "B will hang".

A reasons that it is now a two-way race and his chances have risen to 1/2. Is he right?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Ask what the warden would have said in each of the three cases.

Hint 2

If A is the one pardoned, the warden has a free choice between B and C. If C is pardoned, he has none.

Show the answer Hide the answer

No. A's chance is still 1/3. C's has risen to 2/3.

How to get there

Each prisoner starts with 1/3. Consider what the warden says in each case. If A is pardoned (1/3), the warden may name B or C, say half the time each: so "B" has weight 1/6. If B is pardoned (1/3), he must name C: weight 0. If C is pardoned (1/3), he must name B: weight 1/3.

Given that he said "B", the two live cases carry weights 1/6 and 1/3, so A is pardoned with probability (1/6)/(1/6 + 1/3) = 1/3, and C with probability 2/3.

A learned nothing, because the warden was always going to be able to name one of B and C whatever the truth was. C gained, because "B" was forced in C's case and optional in A's. This is Monty Hall wearing different clothes, and the same question settles both: could the answer have been different?

The technique worth keeping

Condition on what was SAID, not on what it rules out. Weight each underlying case by how likely it was to produce that statement - a statement that was forced is stronger evidence than one that was freely chosen.