The Three Doors

  • Medium
  • Probability puzzles
  • Tests: Noticing that the host’s choice was not free

The puzzle

Three closed doors. Behind one is a car; behind each of the others is a goat. You pick a door. The host, who knows where the car is, opens one of the two you did not pick and shows you a goat.

He now offers you the chance to switch to the remaining closed door. Should you switch, and what are your chances if you do?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

The host was never going to open the door with the car behind it. What does that tell you about the door he left closed?

Hint 2

How often is your first pick right? That number does not change when a goat is revealed.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Switch. Switching wins two times in three; staying wins one time in three.

How to get there

Your first pick is right one time in three. That is fixed before the host does anything, and nothing he does afterwards can change it, because he always opens a goat door whatever you picked.

So two times in three your first pick is wrong - and in every one of those cases the car is behind one of the other two doors. The host has just eliminated the goat among them, so the door he leaves closed is the car.

Staying wins with probability 1/3. Switching wins with probability 2/3. If it still feels wrong, imagine a hundred doors: you pick one, the host opens ninety-eight goats, and the single door he carefully avoided is almost certainly the car.

The technique worth keeping

The host’s action carries information precisely because it was not random. Whenever somebody who knows the answer makes a choice in front of you, ask what they were not allowed to do - that constraint is where the information is hiding.