At Least One Boy

  • Medium
  • Probability puzzles
  • Tests: Listing the cases the condition actually leaves

The puzzle

A family has two children. You are told that at least one of them is a boy. Boys and girls are equally likely and the two births are independent.

What is the probability that both children are boys?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Write down every equally likely family of two children before the condition is applied. There are four, not three.

Hint 2

Which of those four does "at least one boy" rule out?

Show the answer Hide the answer

One in three. Not one in two.

How to get there

In birth order the four equally likely families are BB, BG, GB and GG. Each has probability one quarter.

"At least one is a boy" rules out GG and leaves BB, BG and GB - three cases, still equally likely among themselves.

Only one of those three is two boys, so the answer is 1/3. The intuition that says one half is quietly answering a different question: "the elder is a boy, what about the younger", which really is 1/2, because naming a particular child removes BG or GB rather than only GG.

The technique worth keeping

A condition is a filter on a list of cases, so write the list first and filter it second. Reasoning about the condition directly is what collapses BG and GB into one case and produces the wrong answer.