The Three-Card Swindle

  • Medium
  • Probability puzzles
  • Tests: Counting faces rather than cards

The puzzle

A bag holds three cards. One is red on both sides, one is black on both sides, and one is red on one side and black on the other. You draw a card at random and lay it down without looking at the underside. The face showing is red.

A stranger offers you even money that the other side is also red. Should you take the bet?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

The tempting answer is 1/2: the card is either the red-red one or the mixed one.

Hint 2

Count red faces, not red cards. There are three of them, and they are not equally likely to belong to the same card.

Show the answer Hide the answer

No. The other side is red with probability 2/3, so the stranger wins twice as often as you do.

How to get there

Label the red faces: R1 and R2 on the red-red card, and R3 on the mixed card. You drew a card and a random face landed upwards, so the red face you are looking at is equally likely to be R1, R2 or R3.

Two of those three - R1 and R2 - belong to the red-red card, whose underside is red. Only R3 belongs to the mixed card. So the other side is red with probability 2/3.

The "it is one card or the other, so 1/2" reasoning drops the fact that the red-red card had two chances to show you a red face and the mixed card only one. Seeing red is itself evidence about which card you drew, and the evidence is twice as strong for the red-red card.

The technique worth keeping

When an observation could have arisen in several ways from the same object, count the ways and not the objects. An outcome that a hypothesis produces twice as often is twice as much evidence for it.