Which Hand Was Which?

  • Hard
  • Clock and calendar puzzles
  • Tests: Finding positions valid in both readings

The puzzle

Imagine a clock whose hour and minute hands are exactly the same length and shape, so you cannot tell which is which.

In a twelve-hour period, how many moments are genuinely ambiguous - that is, the two hands could be swapped and still show a valid time, and that time is different from the real one?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

If the hour hand is at angle h, a valid clock has the minute hand at 12h (modulo 360). For the swap to be valid too, you need h = 12 x (12h).

Hint 2

144h = h modulo 360 means 143h is a multiple of 360.

Show the answer Hide the answer

132. There are 143 positions where the swap gives a valid time, but 11 of those are moments when the hands coincide, so the "swapped" time is the same time.

How to get there

Measure both hands in degrees clockwise from 12. On a working clock, if the hour hand is at h then the minute hand is at 12h, reduced modulo 360 - the minute hand goes round twelve times as fast.

For the swapped reading to be a valid time as well, the roles reverse: the hand at 12h must be the hour hand, which forces h = 12 x (12h) = 144h modulo 360. So 143h is a multiple of 360, giving h = 360k/143 for k = 0, 1, ..., 142 - exactly 143 positions in twelve hours.

Some of those are the moments when the hands overlap, which happen when 12h = h modulo 360, so 11h is a multiple of 360: 11 positions. At those the swap changes nothing and the time is not ambiguous. 143 - 11 = 132 genuinely ambiguous moments, which is 143 = 11 x 13 split as 11 coincidences and 11 x 12 ambiguous pairs.

The technique worth keeping

Write each configuration as an equation in one variable, then require both the original and the transformed version to satisfy it. The solutions are a modular arithmetic progression, and the degenerate cases - where the transform does nothing - must be subtracted by hand.