The Ladder and the Tide
The puzzle
A rope ladder hangs over the side of a ship, with its rungs a foot apart and three rungs showing above the water.
The tide rises at a foot an hour. After three hours, how many rungs are above the water?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
The ladder is attached to the ship, not to the sea bed.
Hint 2
What happens to the ship when the tide comes in?
Show the answer Hide the answer
Three - the same as before. The ship floats up with the tide and the ladder rises with it.
How to get there
A ship floats, so it rises exactly as much as the water does.
The ladder is fixed to the ship, so the gap between the lowest visible rung and the water never changes.
Three rungs showing before, three rungs showing after. The arithmetic the puzzle invites - three rungs minus three feet - answers a question about a ladder nailed to the sea floor.
The technique worth keeping
Fix the frame of reference before computing anything. Half of all relative-motion mistakes come from measuring against something that is itself moving.