The Messenger and the Column

  • Hard
  • Work, speed and rate puzzles
  • Tests: Working in the frame of the moving column

The puzzle

A column of soldiers one kilometre long marches at a steady pace. A messenger starts at the back, runs to the front and immediately runs back, arriving at the rear just as the column has advanced exactly one kilometre.

How far did the messenger run?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Let the column move at v and the messenger at u. Going forward he closes at u − v; coming back they approach at u + v.

Hint 2

The total time is the time for the column to cover its own length: 1/v.

Show the answer Hide the answer

About 2.414 km — exactly (1 + √2) kilometres.

How to get there

Forward leg: the messenger gains on the front at u − v and must gain 1 km, so it takes 1/(u − v). Return leg: he and the rear approach at u + v over 1 km, taking 1/(u + v).

The two together equal the column's own time, 1/v. So 1/(u−v) + 1/(u+v) = 1/v. Clearing denominators: 2uv = u² − v², which rearranges to u = v(1 + √2).

The messenger ran for time 1/v at speed u, so his distance is u/v = 1 + √2 = 2.414 km. He covers nearly two and a half times the column's length while the column covers one - which is the measure of how much of his running is spent fighting the column's own motion.

The technique worth keeping

Split a there-and-back into two legs with different relative speeds, and set the total time equal to whatever else is happening meanwhile. The unknown speed cancels into a ratio, which is the quantity the question is really asking for.