Sixty Miles an Hour, Average

  • Medium
  • Work, speed and rate puzzles
  • Tests: Averaging times, not speeds

The puzzle

A car goes up a one-mile hill at 30 mph. How fast must it come down the same mile so that its average speed for the two miles is 60 mph?

90 is the natural answer. It is not just wrong, it is unreachable.

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Average speed is total distance over total time. Work out the time budget.

Hint 2

Two miles at 60 mph takes 1/30 of an hour. How much of that has the climb already spent?

Show the answer Hide the answer

Impossible. The climb alone has already used the entire time budget, so no descent speed - however large - can achieve it.

How to get there

To average 60 mph over 2 miles the whole trip must take 2/60 = 1/30 hour, which is 2 minutes.

The climb is 1 mile at 30 mph, which takes 1/30 hour - 2 minutes. The budget is exhausted before the descent begins, so 2/60 − 1/30 = 0 hours remain.

Descending instantly would give exactly 60 mph and anything slower gives less. Coming down at 90 gives an average of 45, not 60: the harmonic mean 2 × 30 × 90/120 = 45. Average speed is governed by time, and the slow leg dominates the time however fast the other one is.

The technique worth keeping

Average speed is total distance over total time - never the average of the speeds. Convert each leg to a time first, and a demand that leaves zero time is a demand that cannot be met.