The Clock That Gains Five Minutes a Day

  • Medium
  • Clock and calendar puzzles
  • Tests: Knowing how far a clock must drift to be right again

The puzzle

A clock is set correctly at noon on 1 January. It gains exactly 5 minutes every day.

When will it next show the correct time? Note that it is a twelve-hour clock with no am/pm marking.

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

It shows the right time when it is a whole number of full dial revolutions ahead.

Hint 2

A twelve-hour dial repeats every 12 hours, not every 24.

Show the answer Hide the answer

After 144 days - it must gain a full 12 hours, which is 720 minutes, at 5 minutes a day.

How to get there

A clock shows the correct time when its error is a whole number of dial revolutions. On a twelve-hour dial one revolution is 12 hours = 720 minutes.

Gaining 5 minutes a day, it needs 720/5 = 144 days to be a full revolution ahead. So at noon on day 144 it reads noon again and is right.

In between it is never right, because the error passes through every value from 0 to 720 minutes without ever landing back on 0. On a twenty-four-hour clock the error would need to reach 1440 minutes, taking 288 days - twice as long, because such a dial does not repeat at half a day.

The technique worth keeping

A drifting instrument reads correctly when its error equals a whole period of the display, not when the error is zero. Identify the period first - twelve hours for a clock face - then divide.