At Least One Six in Four Rolls

  • Medium
  • Probability puzzles
  • Tests: Turning "at least one" into "not none"

The puzzle

A seventeenth-century gambler made money betting that he would roll at least one six in four throws of a die. He then offered the same bet on at least one double-six in twenty-four throws of two dice, reasoning that 24 is to 36 as 4 is to 6, and lost steadily.

What is the probability of at least one six in four rolls - and what is it for the second bet?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Adding 1/6 four times gives 2/3, which is wrong: the events overlap.

Hint 2

Work out the chance of no six at all, then subtract from 1.

Show the answer Hide the answer

671/1296, about 51.8% - a winning bet. The double-six bet pays off only 49.1% of the time, which is why he lost.

How to get there

The chance of missing a six on one roll is 5/6, and the rolls are independent, so the chance of missing on all four is (5/6)^4 = 625/1296. At least one six is therefore 1 - 625/1296 = 671/1296 = 0.5177.

Just above even, so the bet wins in the long run - by about 1.8 percentage points, which is enough to live on.

The second bet: the chance of no double-six in 24 throws is (35/36)^24 = 0.5086, so at least one double-six has probability 0.4914 - just below even. The proportional reasoning fails because probabilities of repeated misses multiply rather than scale. To match the first bet he needed 25 throws, not 24.

The technique worth keeping

For "at least one", compute the probability of none and subtract from 1. Independent misses multiply, so the complement is a single power - whereas adding the individual chances double-counts every overlap.