Achilles and the Tortoise

  • Medium
  • Mathematical puzzles
  • Tests: Seeing that infinitely many steps can take finite time

The puzzle

Achilles runs at 10 m/s, a tortoise at 1 m/s, and the tortoise starts 10 m ahead. By the time Achilles reaches where the tortoise was, it has moved on. By the time he reaches THAT point, it has moved again - and so on, for ever.

The argument says he never catches it. He plainly does. Where exactly does the argument go wrong?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Add up the times of the stages rather than counting the stages.

Hint 2

The stages get shorter and shorter. Infinitely many of them can still add to a finite total.

Show the answer Hide the answer

The argument is right that there are infinitely many stages and wrong to conclude they take for ever. The times form a convergent series: Achilles catches the tortoise after 10/9 of a second.

How to get there

Stage one takes 10/10 = 1 s, in which the tortoise moves 1 m. Stage two covers that 1 m in 0.1 s, in which the tortoise moves 0.1 m. Each stage is a tenth of the last.

The total time is 1 + 0.1 + 0.01 + … = 1/(1 − 0.1) = 10/9 seconds. Infinitely many terms, finite sum. The same shape with a halving ratio gives 1 + 1/2 + 1/4 + … = 1/(1 − 0.5) = 2.

So the paradox is not about motion at all - it is about the unstated assumption that infinitely many things must add to infinity. Checking directly: the gap closes at 9 m/s and starts at 10 m, so it closes in 10/9 s, exactly where the series says.

The technique worth keeping

An infinite sum of shrinking terms can be finite. When a geometric series has ratio r below 1, its total is first term divided by (1 − r) - and any paradox resting on "infinitely many steps take for ever" dissolves there.