How Far Over the Edge?

  • Hard
  • Mathematical puzzles
  • Tests: Stacking from the top down

The puzzle

Identical books are stacked at the edge of a table, each one allowed to overhang the one below. Nothing is glued and nothing may topple.

How far past the edge can the top book reach with four books? And is there a limit however many you use?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Build it from the top down. The top book can overhang the second by half its length before it tips.

Hint 2

At each stage the stack above must have its centre of mass over the edge of the book below.

Show the answer Hide the answer

With four books, 1.042 book-lengths - already past the edge by more than a whole book. And there is no limit: with enough books the overhang grows without bound, though absurdly slowly.

How to get there

Work downwards. The top book overhangs the one below by 1/2. The top two together have their centre of mass 1/4 from the second book's edge, so that pair can overhang the third by 1/4. The top three can overhang the fourth by 1/6.

The pattern is that the n-th book from the top adds 1/(2n), so the total overhang with n books is (1/2)(1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + … + 1/n). For four books that is (1/2)(2.0833) = 1.042 book-lengths.

The bracket is the harmonic series, which grows without limit - so the overhang does too, and a stack can in principle reach any distance. It does so desperately slowly: two book-lengths needs 31 books, three needs 227, and ten needs about 272 million.

The technique worth keeping

For a balance problem, build from the free end and require at each step that everything above has its centre of mass over the support below. The running centre of mass is the quantity to track, not the individual pieces.