Three Hats, Two Colours

  • Medium
  • Logical puzzles
  • Tests: Using other people's hesitation

The puzzle

Three people are shown five hats: three white and two black. They are blindfolded, a hat is put on each, and the remaining two are hidden. The blindfolds come off - but the third person is blind and sees nothing.

The first says "I do not know my colour." The second says the same. The blind third person then names their own hat correctly. What is it, and how?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

What would the first person have seen in order to know at once?

Hint 2

Two black hats exist. If the first saw both of them, they would know their own was white.

Show the answer Hide the answer

White.

How to get there

If the first person saw black on both others, they would know theirs was white - only two black hats exist. Their "I do not know" rules that out: the second and third are not both black.

The second person now knows that. If the second saw black on the third, then since the two of them are not both black, the second would know their own was white. The second says no - so the third is not black.

The blind person hears both answers, follows exactly that reasoning, and names white. They never needed to see anything: the two admissions of ignorance carried all the information, which is why the blind player is the one who can solve it.

The technique worth keeping

Ask what each speaker would have needed to see in order to answer, and strike those cases out. Hesitation is evidence, and in these puzzles it is usually the only evidence there is.