This Sentence Is False

  • Medium
  • Logical puzzles
  • Tests: Recognising a sentence that cannot have a truth value

The puzzle

Consider the sentence: "This sentence is false."

Is it true or false? And what should we conclude from the fact that neither works?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Try assuming it is true, and read what it then says about itself.

Hint 2

A sentence is not guaranteed to have a truth value simply because it is grammatical.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Neither. The sentence does not express a proposition that can be true or false - it is a grammatical string that fails to say anything determinate.

How to get there

If it is true, then what it says is the case, and what it says is that it is false. So it is false. If it is false, then what it says is not the case, and what it says is that it is false - so it is true.

Both assignments contradict themselves, so the sentence has no truth value. That is not a failure of our reasoning; it is a fact about the sentence.

The reason is self-reference combined with negation. "This sentence is true" is harmless - both assignments are consistent, so it simply has no determinate value either. Formal systems avoid the whole family by forbidding a language from containing its own truth predicate, which is Tarski's result and the same move that answers the barber.

The technique worth keeping

Grammar does not guarantee meaning. When both truth values are self-defeating, the right conclusion is that the sentence expresses no proposition - the same diagnosis as the barber who cannot exist.