The Tap and the Leak

  • Medium
  • Work, speed and rate puzzles
  • Tests: Subtracting one rate from another

The puzzle

A tap can fill a cistern in 6 hours. A leak in the bottom can empty the full cistern in 10 hours.

If the tap is turned on while the leak is open, how long does the cistern take to fill?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Work in fractions of the cistern per hour rather than in hours.

Hint 2

The tap adds 1/6 per hour and the leak removes 1/10. Net fill rate?

Show the answer Hide the answer

15 hours.

How to get there

The tap fills 1/6 of the cistern each hour. The leak empties 1/10 each hour. Running together, the net rate is 1/6 - 1/10 = 5/30 - 3/30 = 2/30 = 1/15 of the cistern per hour.

At 1/15 per hour, filling the whole cistern takes 15 hours.

The net rate is positive, so it does fill - but only just, and the delay is dramatic: 6 hours becomes 15. Had the leak emptied it in 6 hours instead of 10 the rates would cancel exactly and the cistern would never fill at all, and a faster leak would make the level fall.

The technique worth keeping

Convert every "takes t hours" into a rate of 1/t per hour, then add the rates with the right signs. Rates combine by addition where times do not, which is the single idea behind every pipes-and-cisterns question.