Three Coins, One Light

  • Easy
  • Measuring and weighing
  • Tests: Reading a balance's third outcome

The puzzle

Three coins look identical. Two are genuine and weigh the same; the third is counterfeit and slightly lighter.

You have a two-pan balance. Find the counterfeit in one weighing.

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

You do not have to put all three coins on the balance.

Hint 2

A balance has three possible outcomes, not two.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Weigh coin A against coin B. If one rises it is the fake; if they balance, coin C is the fake.

How to get there

Put A in the left pan and B in the right, leaving C aside. If the left pan rises, A is light and is the counterfeit. If the right pan rises, B is.

If the pans balance, A and B are both genuine, so the coin you never weighed is the counterfeit.

The coin left off the balance is doing real work here. A weighing tells you which of three things happened - left light, right light, or equal - so one weighing can single out one of three candidates, and that is exactly the number you have.

The technique worth keeping

A balance is a three-way test, not a yes/no one. Count the outcomes before planning: n weighings distinguish up to 3^n cases, and the group you set aside is one of the three answers.